Monster Origins
Re: Monster Origins
Apes that eat meat are not new, but they are not called "Carnivorous Ape".
If I google "carnivorous ape" and all the hits are from D&D, it's not a good sign.
If I google vampire, for example, there are no D&D hits on the first page.
A rename here would seem prudent.
If I google "carnivorous ape" and all the hits are from D&D, it's not a good sign.
If I google vampire, for example, there are no D&D hits on the first page.
A rename here would seem prudent.
Re: Monster Origins
Conan has fought carnivorous apes, that were noted as such, also two common words together are not protectable, unless they are a unique expression, especially not if there exists in the world actual creatures that term describes.Seven wrote: ↑Sun Jan 15, 2023 10:15 pm Apes that eat meat are not new, but they are not called "Carnivorous Ape".
If I google "carnivorous ape" and all the hits are from D&D, it's not a good sign.
If I google vampire, for example, there are no D&D hits on the first page.
A rename here would seem prudent.
Found the reference, it was in Conan the Freebooter, by Robert E. Howard and L. Sprague de Camp, published in 1968, and according to this article is almost certainly the inspiration for D&D
https://appendixnbookclub.com/2018/06/1 ... -nogueira/
Last edited by Boggo on Sun Jan 15, 2023 10:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
No matter where you go...there you are
Re: Monster Origins
Hmm Arthur Conan Doyle seems to have had carnivorous apes in The Lost World as well (I don't remember them but I did just find 2 references (though one was to a tv series based on the book))
No matter where you go...there you are
Re: Monster Origins
From Borges' book:
The Golem is a jewish myth. "It was said of demons that they could make large and bulky creatures... but were incapable of creating anything delicate and frail...
Der Golem, a book by Gustav Meyrink, 1915. "A rabbi made an artificial man... by the power of a magic tablet which was placed under his tongue... One night, the rabbi forgot to take the tablet out... and the creature fell into a frenzy."
The flesh golem is Frankenstein's monster.
Jason had "bulls with brass feet and horns that breathed flames". Condillac has a statue of "sensitive marble". The boatman in the Arabian Night is "a man of brass with a tablet of lead on his breast inscribed with talismans...". There's also metal birds who nursed Ares. There is the boar "Gullinbursti", "This living piece of metalwork came from the forges of skilful dwarves". And then, there is Talos, the man of bronze.
Lizardmen are very popular as some sort of Qanon/illuminati conspiracy according to which important people are aliens. Who knew? Closest after that are Howard's Serpent men.
The concept is fine, but an alternate name might be a good idea. Reptilians?
Re: Monster Origins
Rogues in the House, by Howard. Published in 1934.
Features "an intelligent ape-like hominid".
In actuality, the creatures are probably omnivore.
Carnivorous Apes as a name only makes sense if there are also vegetarian apes around.
The basic set I started with didn't have Beholders and Umber Hulks but I'm pretty sure it had Carnivorous Apes.
Features "an intelligent ape-like hominid".
In actuality, the creatures are probably omnivore.
Carnivorous Apes as a name only makes sense if there are also vegetarian apes around.
The basic set I started with didn't have Beholders and Umber Hulks but I'm pretty sure it had Carnivorous Apes.
Re: Monster Origins
In The Mermaid's Children by Poul Anderson, the spirit of the suicided is called a Vilja.
- LibraryLass
- Posts: 1057
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2013 10:02 pm
Re: Monster Origins
I can confirm Allips do not appear in D&D prior to 3rd edition. Name arguably comes from German "Alp", meaning an elf, ghost, incubus, or nightmare.leon wrote: ↑Sun Jan 15, 2023 6:53 pm Looks like Aboleth and Skum are originally from I1 Dwellers of the Forbidden City (1981) by David "Zeb" Cook.
Allip seems to appear first in the 3e Monster Manual in 2000. However, a few days ago, Matt said it's from 1e. I know it's not in the 2e MM. Got a reference from 1e?
Re: Monster Origins
I did find the phrase "carnivorous ape" in old books. See this google books search.
"He hunted and killed the horse , the reindeer , the urus , the mammoth , and the seal ; he roasted their flesh and broke their bones for marrow , and finally - to show he was man and not a carnivorous ape - he drew their portraits ." The Journal of Microscopy and Natural Science - Volume 8 - Page 54 1889
The "snow" qualifier is the part that seems unique.
Regarding Golems, I should have said "iron golem". I agree that clay golems are from mythology. All those other clockwork creatures are very nice to have, too.
If we rename lizard people, I'd go with Sciritae, which is the name Pliny the Elder used. But I also like the idea of giving one monster multiple names. For example, giant caecilia is fine, but common folk might call them cave worms. They do in my game, anyway.
"He hunted and killed the horse , the reindeer , the urus , the mammoth , and the seal ; he roasted their flesh and broke their bones for marrow , and finally - to show he was man and not a carnivorous ape - he drew their portraits ." The Journal of Microscopy and Natural Science - Volume 8 - Page 54 1889
The "snow" qualifier is the part that seems unique.
Regarding Golems, I should have said "iron golem". I agree that clay golems are from mythology. All those other clockwork creatures are very nice to have, too.
If we rename lizard people, I'd go with Sciritae, which is the name Pliny the Elder used. But I also like the idea of giving one monster multiple names. For example, giant caecilia is fine, but common folk might call them cave worms. They do in my game, anyway.
I solemnly swear to fulfill the game master's oath to the best of my ability and judgment.
EmptyZ Campaign Blog: emptyz.com/blog
Personal Blog: leonatkinson.com
EmptyZ Campaign Blog: emptyz.com/blog
Personal Blog: leonatkinson.com
- Solomoriah
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12460
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 8:15 pm
- Location: LaBelle, Missouri
- Contact:
Re: Monster Origins
If you can't find an origin for a monster, we are the origin and that's cool.
My personal site: www.gonnerman.org
- Solomoriah
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12460
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 8:15 pm
- Location: LaBelle, Missouri
- Contact:
Re: Monster Origins
Lizard man is obvious, and if the exact thing we have isn't out there somewhere, it doesn't really matter. There's no particular art to calling a humanoid lizard a "lizard man." "Carnivorous ape" falls under that as well, it's an ape that eats meat.
The expression "exactly what it says on the tin" usually applies, as long as the monster is obvious.
Some monsters are another kind of problem. "Rust monsters" are a problem not because they aren't obviously named (it's a monster that rusts things) but because they aren't obvious monsters. As far as I know, before Gary thought of this way to torture players, nobody else did. Whereas, whether they are called "carnivorous ape" or "lizard man" there are plenty of stories pre-TSR that feature such creatures. Gary was, I think, inspired by the white apes of Burrough's Barsoom when he added similar monsters to his own game.
The expression "exactly what it says on the tin" usually applies, as long as the monster is obvious.
Some monsters are another kind of problem. "Rust monsters" are a problem not because they aren't obviously named (it's a monster that rusts things) but because they aren't obvious monsters. As far as I know, before Gary thought of this way to torture players, nobody else did. Whereas, whether they are called "carnivorous ape" or "lizard man" there are plenty of stories pre-TSR that feature such creatures. Gary was, I think, inspired by the white apes of Burrough's Barsoom when he added similar monsters to his own game.
My personal site: www.gonnerman.org
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 49 guests